This is more of a mind dump than any sort of refined thought about the nature of art and what makes art art. Some of this will most likely be wrong and I am fine with that.
Things are usually thought of as being on some sort of sliding scale between utility and art, or utility and utter gratuity. I don’t think things exist on that scale. I have seen Excel spreadsheets that could be considered art. I think the defining parameter for art is whether or not it is beautiful or not. In terms of beauty I think the next step is to say that a thing is beautiful when it is more of what it is.
Therefore a thing that is more of what it is, is more beautiful and therefore is more visible as art. Take a door. First we must define just what a door is. It is a thing that serves many purposes in its utility and how well it functions (opens and closes) must be taken into account. Then we have to look at just what it is to open and what it is to close. Two spaces are separated and a door serves to close them off from each other and then to unite them to each other by removing itself and allowing free passage. A door that is too small for a person to walk through may not be considered a beautiful if it’s utility is to let a person pass through it.
A closed door serves the utility of separating two spaces and from each other. Does the door stand out as the separation or does it blend in to the wall? Does it matter if it does either? How solid is it? How well does it separate? To what degree is it doing what it is intended to do? Is it more of what it is?
An open door joins two spaces. It gets itself out of the way and allows free passage. It creates a portal from one space to the another. Is the portal more of what it is?
So many things to consider if we are to say that a door is a piece of art. Indeed many doors swing wide or slip into their walls and have shape and form that is pleasing and they serve their function and are beautiful. A door can be art and it is an extraordinarily utilitarian thing. Utility is a function of what makes something art.
The beauty of a thing, how well it achieves completion of itself, is the measure of its artfulness.
Lucy loves to dance: quick, slow, jumping high, bending low. She marches, stamps her feet, lifts her legs, crosses her feet, twirls around, and recently mastered the curtsie. She does it all, and gets her inspiration from Balanchine’s The Nutcracker, Disney’s Fantasia and Topol’s Fiddler on the Roof.
